If the State filed charges and the defendant or victim is an Indian, and the crime occurred on an Indian Reservation, the case must be dismissed. If the defendant already pled guilty or was found guilty at trial, the defendant can have the convictions vacated.
If you are an Indian and have an open case or a past conviction, you may be able to have your case dismissed. The State of Oklahoma cannot prosecute a case where the defendant or victim is an Indian if the crime occurred on an Indian reservation. On July 9, 2020, Supreme Court Justice Neil Gorsuch issued an opinion from the United States Supreme Court (McGirt v. Oklahoma) that turned the criminal prosecution world in Eastern Oklahoma upside down. This opinion decided an issue concerning the Muscogee (Creek) Nation and whether their land is an Indian reservation. It stated that the Muscogee (Creek) Nation is still an Indian Reservation. Gorsuch wrote that this land is and always has been an Indian reservation. The opinion only concerned the Muscogee (Creek) Nation, however the Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals ruled that the Cherokee Nation and the Chickasaw Nation are in the same position. The remaining two tribes of the Five Civilized Tribes (Choctaw and Seminole) are expected to follow suit.
What does this mean? It means that a state court does not have the ability to prosecute cases involving Indians if it occurred on an Indian reservation, such as the Muscogee (Creek) Nation, Cherokee Nation and the Chickasaw. The Muscogee (Creek) Nation covers eight counties: Creek, Tulsa, Wagoner, Muskogee, Okmulgee, Okfuskee, McIntosh, and Hughes. The Cherokee Nation covers Tulsa, Washington, Nowata, Rogers, Craig, Mayes, Ottawa, Delaware, Adair, Cheroke Muskogee, and Sequoyah Counties. Chickasaw Nation covers Grady, McClain, Stephens, Garvin, Pontotoc, Murray, Carter, Johnston, Jefferson, Carter, Love, and Marshall Counties. However, it is expected that the remaining two tribes that comprise the Five Civilized Tribes will be found to still be Indian Reservations. This will cover almost the entire eastern half of Oklahoma.
If you have an open case or have a past conviction and an Indian was involved in the matter (defendant or victim), the State of Oklahoma did not have the ability prosecute the matter if it occurred on an Indian reservation. If you think you or someone you know falls in this category, please call or email Ben Hilfiger at Cook and Hilfiger to schedule a consultation.
Ben Hilfiger, Attorney at Law
(918) 218-2817
ben@cookhilfiger.com
Share On: